Meiloz · Custom cast iron cookware manufacturer. Private label & OEM from 500 pcs. FDA / LFGB compliant.

Short answer: an inclusive quote is not a price, it is a bundle, and the only fair comparison is cost per sellable unit delivered to the same place. Get both factories to quote the same written packaging specification, at the same order quantity and on the same Incoterm, and then add three things to the unit price: the packaging cost you would otherwise buy yourself, the freight penalty when a bigger carton cuts the number of units per container, and the working capital change from a different deposit structure. Any one of the three can reverse the ranking.

What Does “Packaging Included” Actually Cover?

Packaging is a stack of layers, and two factories can both say “included” while quoting different heights of the stack. Pin down the layer before you compare the number:

Layer What it is Usual culprit
Unit protection Polybag, tissue, foam corner, moulded insert Quoted as “standard” on one side, priced separately on the other
Retail carton Printed colour box or brown box, board grade, print method Included by one factory, treated as a customer-supplied item by the other
Inner and master carton Carton quantity, dimensions, gross weight, barcode label Changes the cube, which changes freight — see below
Pallet and loading Pallet type, pattern, stretch wrap, corner boards Often unpriced until the load plan exists
Artwork and plates Dieline, print plates, colour proofing One-time cost that gets absorbed into a unit price and then never removed
Testing Drop test of the parcel configuration, transport simulation Named in one quote, silent in the other

A quote that includes “packaging” but not the drop test is not the same offer as one that includes both. The layers, not the total, are what you are buying.

What Should the Packaging Specification Contain?

To compare like with like, write one specification and send it to both factories. Nine fields are enough to make the quotes answer the same question:

  1. Dieline — the flat layout, either yours or the factory’s, with a stated board grade.
  2. Board and flute — grade and construction, stated as a named grade rather than “good quality”.
  3. Print method and colours — offset, flexo or digital, plus the colour reference and whether a proof is required before production.
  4. Units per carton — the packing quantity, not a range.
  5. Carton dimensions and gross weight — measured, because these two numbers set your freight.
  6. Internal protection — insert type, corner protection, and whether a moisture barrier is included.
  7. Barcode and labels — symbology, placement, and whether the factory prints or you supply.
  8. Pallet and loading — pallet type, stacking pattern, wrap and corner boards, so the loading plan is priced rather than discovered at booking.
  9. Test requirement — the drop or transport test the packaging must pass, and who runs it.

Meiloz describes its packaging offer as brown box or colour box to start, with a drop-test-passing e-commerce pack for online sellers and a retail-grade dieline the buyer can adapt. Whatever the factory offers, the specification you send is what makes the two quotes answerable.

Worker sanding the cooking face of a cast iron pan on a wide abrasive belt at a finishing station

Why Must Both Quotes Be at Your Real Order Quantity?

Quotes at different quantities are not comparable, and the gap is largest exactly where cast iron lives. Custom and private-label work at Meiloz starts at 500 pcs per SKU, public-mould stock items at 1,000 pcs, and in-stock items from 100 pcs. A factory that quotes 5,000 units against your 800-unit order is quoting a different manufacturing setup, a different mould amortisation and a different packaging print run.

Two rules follow. First, ask for the price at your real quantity, and ask what the next tier up would cost — the difference tells you whether the tier is worth consolidating two SKUs to reach. Second, ask what the tooling and packaging plate cost is, and whether it is amortised into the unit price or invoiced once. A mould fee that is spread across a small order can make a competitive unit price look worse than it is, and a plate cost that is silently absorbed never comes off on reorder.

On the cast iron side the tooling economics are visible: a small mould starts at $150 and includes two confirmation samples, and repeat orders skip the mould fee because the mould is stored for the account. Ask both factories to state that in writing, because a quote that hides a per-order tooling charge is not cheaper — it is just cheaper on page one.

How Does a Bigger Carton Change Freight per Unit?

This is where the packaging difference stops being a rounding error. How freight is billed depends on the mode: a full container is priced per container, so the bill does not move with a few extra kilos but the number of units inside does; less-than-container and parcel shipments are billed on chargeable weight, which is the greater of actual and volumetric weight. Either way a retail-ready carton is bigger than a plain export carton, so it loses on volume before it loses on weight:

  • Units per container fall. If a bigger carton cuts the units per container, the same ocean freight is spread across fewer sellable units.
  • Pallets per shipment rise. More pallets means more handling at both ends, and often a different loading pattern.
  • Parcel costs diverge. If any units ship direct to consumers, a retail box that passes a drop test is the correct spend; a retail box that fails is a damage claim.

The arithmetic is simple enough to run before you ask for a second quote. Take one container’s freight cost and divide it by the units that container holds for each packaging option — that quotient is the freight per unit. Do not divide a multi-container freight bill by a single container’s unit count. Then compare that figure against the packaging cost difference per unit. When volume is the binding constraint, packaging that looks cheap per carton can be expensive per unit delivered.

How Do You Turn All of This into One Comparable Number?

Use cost per sellable unit delivered, and build it as four lines rather than one:

  1. Product unit price at your real quantity, with tooling treated separately or amortised explicitly over the expected order life.
  2. Packaging cost per unit — either the factory’s inclusive line, or the factory line plus your own packaging supplier’s quote, converted to per unit at the specified units per carton.
  3. Freight and duty per unit — total freight divided by units per container for the specified packaging, plus duty at the applicable rate.
  4. Financing cost per unit — the deposit percentage multiplied by your cost of capital for the production lead time. Meiloz quotes a 40% deposit with 60% against the bill-of-lading copy; a factory asking for a higher deposit is asking you to fund its working capital, and that has a price.

Add the four lines and you have a number that survives a board review. Two cautions. First, keep the currency and the Incoterm identical across both columns — the ICC’s Incoterms framework is the common vocabulary, and a quote that is silent on the term is not a quote. Second, do not let a favourable exchange rate sit inside the comparison: ask each factory for the currency and the rate basis, and if one quotes in a currency you do not buy in, convert at your own rate and keep the exposure visible.

What Else Hides in the Gap?

Three things show up after the comparison, and they are worth asking about before you award:

  • Quote validity. A price with a 30-day validity and a price valid for six months are different offers when board and freight move. Ask for the validity window and what triggers a re-quote.
  • Who owns the packaging plates. If the factory owns the print plates and the dieline, moving suppliers later means paying to reproduce both. Ask for ownership in writing, and ask whether the plates travel with the account.
  • What inspection is included. A final inspection report is a documented step, not an assumption; third-party inspection should be the buyer’s option, booked early enough to matter. Meiloz runs a final inspection and issues a report, and accepts inspection arranged by the buyer.

Confidentiality belongs on the list too if the carton carries your brand. A packaging specification that includes your artwork is a design file; ask what the factory’s confidentiality position is before it leaves your inbox. Meiloz states that it runs custom projects under an NDA and holds the mould for the account.

For a first private-label order, the practical sequence is: agree the packaging specification, ask both factories to quote that specification at your real quantity, then compare delivered cost per unit and only afterwards negotiate. Starting with the unit price is how a cheaper quote becomes an expensive order. The custom and private-label program sets out the tooling, sampling and packaging terms in one place, and the manufacturing page covers the process behind the quote.

الأسئلة الشائعة

Can I just ask the cheaper factory to add packaging and compare the new number?

Yes, and you should — but ask for the packaging as a separate line with the same specification, not as a revised lump sum. A lump sum hides the per-unit packaging cost, and that is the number you need when the carton or the print run changes.

What if one factory refuses to quote packaging separately?

Treat that as information. Either the packaging margin is doing work in the quote, or the factory is buying cartons in a volume it does not want to disclose. You can still compare, but ask for the carton dimensions, units per carton and board grade so the freight line can be normalised.

How do I compare quotes in different currencies?

Convert both at your own rate on the same date, and keep the rate basis next to the number. A quote in a currency you do not buy in transfers the exchange risk to you, which is a cost even when the headline number looks lower.

Is a higher deposit always worse?

It is a financing cost, not a discount. Convert the difference into a per-unit cost over the production lead time and add it to the comparison. If the higher-deposit factory is still cheaper after that line, the deposit is not the deciding factor.

Should the drop test be in the quote?

If the packaging is specified to pass one, yes — as a named test with a named party running it. A quote that lists the carton but not the test is quoting a box, not a validated packaging system.

What is the fastest way to normalise two quotes?

Send both the same eight-field packaging specification and the same order quantity, and ask each to return the four cost lines separately. Two spreadsheets that answer the same question take an hour; two lump sums take a week and still end in an argument.

Source this at Meiloz

Share this article

Planning your next cast iron collection?

Foundry-direct pricing, custom molds from 500 pcs, and FDA / LFGB food-safe compliance. Send us your designs or concepts and we reply within one working day.

احصل على عرض أسعار مجاني
Back to top
Need a fast quotation? Chat with our export team on WhatsApp.